Study | FOG, % ( n of freezer/n of PD patients) | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
In general PD patients | Duration < 5 years | Duration ≥ 5 years | Duration ≥ 10 years | H&Y ≤ 2.5 | H&Y > 2.5 | |
Margolesky et al [36] | 26.5% (27/102) | |||||
Mckay et al [46] | 40.0% (26/65)c | 33.3% (15/45) | 55.0% (11/20) | |||
Mancini et al [40] | 26.6% (25/94)a | |||||
Djaldetti et al [37] | 34.8% (15/41) | 34.8% (15/41) | ||||
Ehgoetz Martens et al [38] | 41.6% (92/221) | |||||
Kader et al [44] | 56.8% (138/243)a | |||||
Sutter et al [45] | 41.4% (46/111)a | 37.0% (34/92) | 63.2% (12/19) | |||
Forsyth et al [43] | 39.0% (30/82)a | |||||
Ricciardi et al [41] | 55.8% (24/43)* | |||||
Vervoort et al [42] | 22.4% (17/76)a | |||||
Shin et al [35] | 38.6% (54/141) | 29.2% (21/73) | 48.4% (31/64) | 59.1% (13/22) | ||
Allen et al [21] | 49.4% (114/231) | |||||
Amboni et al [11] | 54.8% (325/593)a | 27.4% (48/175) | 65.8% (271/412) | 78.3% (148/189) | 35.3% (124/351) | 82.9% (194/234) |
Forsaa et al [22] | 27.2% (63/232) b | 62.5% (145/232) | ||||
Gazibara et al [23] | 36.7% (110/300) | |||||
Lieberman et al [24] | 12.7% (27/212) | |||||
Lindholm et al [25] | 41.1% (58/141)a | |||||
Walton et al [26] | 42.4% (86/203) a | |||||
Bohnen et al [8] | 14.0% (20/143) | |||||
Ou et al [27] | 46.6% (221/474) a | 36.1% (108/299) | 64.6% (113/175) | 33.5% (115/343) | 82.2% (106/129) | |
Perez-Lloret et al [28] | 38.2% (257/672) b | 25.4% (85/335) | 51.0% (172/337) | 31.5% (174/553) | 60.0% (150/250) | |
Auyeung et al [10] | 86.5% (148/171) | |||||
Contreras et al [29] | 44.4% (71/160)a | |||||
Garcia-Ruiz et al [30] | 4.4% (2/45) | 44.4% (20/45) | 68.9% (31/45) | |||
Josiah et al [31] | 41.5% (380/916)b | |||||
Coelho et al [32] | 62.0% (31/50) | 62.0% (31/50) | ||||
Moore et al [9] | 55.1% (65/118) a | |||||
Giladi et al (2001) | 7.1% (57/800) | |||||
Giladi et al (2001) | 53.5% (92/172) | 22.2% (10/45) | 63.8% (81/127) |