From: Ectopic recurrence craniopharyngioma: series report and literature review
Researcher | Age (year) | Gender | Initial pathology | Previous treatment | Ectopic recurrence location | Tumor size (cm) | Ectopic recurrence pathology | Ectopic recurrence mechanism | Interval after initial (year) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Present study | 63 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd TSS STR | R temporal lobe | 2.6 × 1.3 | ACP (Ki-67 = 5%) | CSF | 3 |
49 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio STR + GK 2nd cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 1st 5.7 × 4.3; 2nd 3.4 × 2.1 | ACP (1st KI-67 = 3% 2nd Ki-67 = 2%) | Surgical approach | 1st 7 2nd 16 | |
Cai (2019) [7] | 28 | Male | ACP (Ki-67 = 10%) | Cranio GTR | R temporal lobe | 6 × 4 × 5 | ACP (Ki-67 = 20%) | CSF | 1 |
Renfrow (2018) [8] | 14 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio GTR 2nd cranio GTR 3rd RT | L lateral ventricle | 1.2 | ACP | CSF | 12 |
Mahdi (2018) [9] | 24 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | R CPA | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 5%) | CSF | 1 |
Jian (2017) [10] | 42 | Male | PCP | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 5 × 4 | PCP (Ki-67 = 3%) | CSF | 0.3 |
Carleton-Bland (2017) [11] | 10 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio STR + RT | R lateral ventricle | 2 × 1.8 | ACP | CSF | 2 |
Du (2017) [12] | 6 | Female | ACP | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 6.5 × 5 × 6 | ACP (Ki-67 = 1%) | Surgical approach | 5 |
4 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | Fourth ventricle | Unclear | ACP (Ki-67 = 1%) | CSF | 4 | |
Clark (2015) [13] | 33 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio GTR 2nd cranio GTR | L Sylvian fissure | 3.2 × 2.2 | ACP | Surgical approach | 34 |
Yang (2015) [14] | 35 | Male | Unclear | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 6 × 5.5 × 5 | PCP (Ki-67 = 1%) | Surgical approach | 9 |
46 | Male | PCP (Ki-67 = 2%) | Cranio GTR | Interhemisphere | 2.2 × 1.7 × 1.4 | PCP (Ki-67 = 5%) | Surgical approach | 2 | |
42 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio GTR 2nd cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 5.5 × 5 × 5 | ACP (Ki-67 = 1%) | Surgical approach | 6 | |
Gonçalves (2014) [15] | 49 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 3 | ACP | Surgical approach | 5 |
Jakobs (2012) [16] | 61 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio GTR 2nd RT | R frontal bone | 1.9 × 1.8 | ACP (Ki-67 = 5%) | Surgical approach | 11 |
Elfving (2011) [17] | 4 | Female | ACP (KI-67 < 1%) | 1st cranio GTR 2nd cranio STR + RT | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = focal 15%) | Surgical approach | 11 |
Salunke (2011) [18] | 5 | Female | Unclear | Cranio STR | R Sylvian fissure | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 0.92 |
de Blank (2011) [19] | 5 | Female | Unclear | 1st cranio GTR 2nd RT | L CPA | 4.5 × 4.1 | Unclear | Surgical approach | 17 |
Kordes (2011) [20] | 7 | Male | ACP | Cranio PR + TSS + RT | R parietal lobe | 2 | ACP | Surgical approach | 1.25 |
Wang (2010) [21] | 3 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR + RT | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 2 |
Lermen (2010) [22] | 45 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio GTR | Lumber space | Unclear | ACP | CSF | 0.5 |
Schmalisch 2010 [23] | 11 | Male | ACP (KI-67 = 1%) | Cranio GTR | R Sylvian fissure | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 2%) | Surgical approach | 2 |
23 | Female | ACP (KI-67 = 8%) | 1st cranio STR 2nd TSS | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 8%) | Surgical approach | 4 | |
32 | Male | ACP (KI-67 = 2%) | Cranio GTR | R parietal lobe | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 5%) | CSF | 10 | |
Romani (2010) [24] | 18 | Female | ACP | Cranio GTR | Interhemisphere | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 4 |
Frangou (2009) [25] | 10 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio STR 3rd cranio STR + RT | R parietal lobe | Unclear | ACP | CSF | 4 |
Elliott (2009) [26] | 3 | Female | ACP | Cranio GTR | Prepontine cistern | 0.5 | ACP | CSF | 10 |
2 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio GTR 3rd cranio GTR | L CPA | 1.5 | ACP | CSF | 3.5 | |
3 | Female | ACP | Cranio GTR | R Sylvian fissure | 2 | ACP | Surgical approach | 1.67 | |
6 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio GTR | L frontal lobe | 1 | ACP | CSF | 7.08 | |
Bikmaz (2009) [27] | 37 | Female | Unclear | Unclear | Prepontine | Unclear | ACP | CSF | 15 |
32 | Male | Unclear | GTR | R frontal lobe | Unclear | Non-ACP | Surgical approach | 9 | |
12 | Male | Unclear | STR + RT | B CPA | Unclear | Unclear | CSF | 12 | |
Novák (2008) [28] | 48 | Male | Unclear | Unclear | Posterior fossa | Unclear | Unclear | CSF | 19 |
Jeong (2006) [29] | 8 | Female | ACP (KI-67 = 3%) | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 3%) | Surgical approach | 4 |
Yamada (2006) [31] | 17 | Female | ACP (KI-67 = 4.2%) | Cranio STR + RT | L frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP (KI-67 = 7.4%) | CSF | 5 |
Bianco (2005) [31] | 27 | Female | ACP | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio GTR | L temporal lobe cortex | 1 | ACP | Surgical approach | 10 |
Kawaguchi (2005) [32] | 50 | Female | Unclear | 1st unclear 2nd cranio GTR | L frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 2 |
Ishiia (2004) [33] | 2 | Male | Unclear | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 0.17 |
Liu (2002) [34] | 65 | Female | Unclear | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 4.5 × 6.2 × 3 | ACP | Surgical approach | 3 |
Nomura (2002) [35] | 17 | Female | ACP (KI-67 = 3%) | 1st cranio STR 2nd cranio STR + RT | R frontal and temporal lobe | Unclear | ACP (F MIB = 6.2%, T MIB = 5.1%) | CSF | 3.92 |
Fuentes (2002) [36] | 32 | Male | ACP | GTR | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 5 |
11 | Male | ACP | GTR | Unclear | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 3 | |
9 | Male | ACP | GTR | R frontal lobe R temporal lobe | Unclear | ACP | Surgical approach | 10 | |
Elmaci (2002) [37] | 62 | Female | PCP (KI-67 = 1%) | Cranio GTR | L temporal lobe | 4 × 3 × 2.5 | PCP (KI-67 = 3%) | CSF | 2 |
Novegno (2002) [38] | 6 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | 1st L frontal lobe 2nd L pontine R cerebral basal | Unclear | Unclear | 1st surgical approach 2nd CSF | 1st 3 2nd 4 |
Lee (2001) [39] | 26 | Male | PCP | Cranio STR + GK | Lumber space | Unclear | PCP | CSF | 1.58 |
Ito (2001) [40] | 62 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | Unclear | ACP | CSF | 3 |
Freitag (2001) [41] | 61 | Female | Unclear | Unclear | R frontal lobe | Unclear | Unclear | Surgical approach | 5 |
Kim (2001) [42] | Child | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | Internal auditory canal | Unclear | Unclear | CSF | Unclear |
Gupta (1999) [43] | 73 | Male | ACP | Cranio GTR | L parietal lobe and L frontal lobe | 2 | ACP | CSF | 7 |
Lee (1999) [44] | 31 | Male | Unclear | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 1 | Unclear | Surgical approach | 5 |
Israel (1995) [45] | 12 | Male | Unclear | Cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 4 | Unclear | Surgical approach | 2 |
Keohane (1994) [46] | 7 | Female | Unclear | Cranio STR + RT | L CPA | Unclear | ACP | CSF | 26 |
Tomita (1993) [47] | Child | Unclear | Unclear | Unclear | R frontal lobe | Unclear | Unclear | Surgical approach | Unclear |
Malik (1992) [48] | 6 | Male | ACP | 1st cranio PR + RT 2nd cranio PR 3rd cranio GTR | R frontal lobe | 3.5 | ACP | Surgical approach | 21 |
Tomita (1992) [49] | 23 | Female | Unclear | 1st cranio PR 2nd RT | R CPA, interpeduncle, prepontine | Unclear | Unclear | CSF | 25 |
Gökalp (1991) [50] | 3 | Male | Unclear | Cranio GTR | Fourth ventricle | 3 × 3 × 3 | Unclear | CSF | 20 |
Ragoowansi (1991) [51] | 47 | Male | Unclear | 1st stereotactic biopsy 2nd cranio GTR | R Sylvian fissure | 2.5 × 1.5 | Unclear | Surgical approach | 1 |
Barloon (1988) [52] | 5 | Male | Unclear | 1st cranio STR RT and cyst aspiration | R frontal lobe | Unclear | Unclear | Surgical approach | 5 |
Baba (1978) [53] | 7 | Female | Unclear | Cranio STR | Prepontine C3 | Unclear | Unclear | CSF | 7 |