Skip to main content

Table 1 The characteristics of ectopic recurrence craniopharyngioma

From: Ectopic recurrence craniopharyngioma: series report and literature review

Researcher

Age (year)

Gender

Initial pathology

Previous treatment

Ectopic recurrence location

Tumor size (cm)

Ectopic recurrence pathology

Ectopic recurrence mechanism

Interval after initial (year)

Present study

63

Female

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd TSS STR

R temporal lobe

2.6 × 1.3

ACP (Ki-67 = 5%)

CSF

3

49

Female

ACP

1st cranio STR + GK

2nd cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

1st 5.7 × 4.3; 2nd 3.4 × 2.1

ACP

(1st KI-67 = 3%

2nd Ki-67 = 2%)

Surgical approach

1st 7

2nd 16

Cai (2019) [7]

28

Male

ACP (Ki-67 = 10%)

Cranio GTR

R temporal lobe

6 × 4 × 5

ACP (Ki-67 = 20%)

CSF

1

Renfrow (2018) [8]

14

Female

ACP

1st cranio GTR

2nd cranio GTR

3rd RT

L lateral ventricle

1.2

ACP

CSF

12

Mahdi (2018) [9]

24

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

R CPA

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 5%)

CSF

1

Jian (2017) [10]

42

Male

PCP

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

5 × 4

PCP

(Ki-67 = 3%)

CSF

0.3

Carleton-Bland (2017) [11]

10

Male

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio STR + RT

R lateral ventricle

2 × 1.8

ACP

CSF

2

Du (2017) [12]

6

Female

ACP

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

6.5 × 5 × 6

ACP (Ki-67 = 1%)

Surgical approach

5

4

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

Fourth ventricle

Unclear

ACP (Ki-67 = 1%)

CSF

4

Clark (2015) [13]

33

Female

ACP

1st cranio GTR

2nd cranio GTR

L Sylvian fissure

3.2 × 2.2

ACP

Surgical approach

34

Yang (2015) [14]

35

Male

Unclear

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

6 × 5.5 × 5

PCP (Ki-67 = 1%)

Surgical approach

9

46

Male

PCP (Ki-67 = 2%)

Cranio GTR

Interhemisphere

2.2 × 1.7 × 1.4

PCP (Ki-67 = 5%)

Surgical approach

2

42

Male

ACP

1st cranio GTR

2nd cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

5.5 × 5 × 5

ACP (Ki-67 = 1%)

Surgical approach

6

Gonçalves (2014) [15]

49

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

3

ACP

Surgical approach

5

Jakobs (2012) [16]

61

Female

ACP

1st cranio GTR

2nd RT

R frontal bone

1.9 × 1.8

ACP (Ki-67 = 5%)

Surgical approach

11

Elfving (2011) [17]

4

Female

ACP (KI-67 < 1%)

1st cranio GTR

2nd cranio STR + RT

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = focal 15%)

Surgical approach

11

Salunke (2011) [18]

5

Female

Unclear

Cranio STR

R Sylvian fissure

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

0.92

de Blank (2011) [19]

5

Female

Unclear

1st cranio GTR

2nd RT

L CPA

4.5 × 4.1

Unclear

Surgical approach

17

Kordes (2011) [20]

7

Male

ACP

Cranio PR + TSS + RT

R parietal lobe

2

ACP

Surgical approach

1.25

Wang (2010) [21]

3

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR + RT

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

2

Lermen (2010) [22]

45

Male

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio GTR

Lumber space

Unclear

ACP

CSF

0.5

Schmalisch 2010 [23]

11

Male

ACP (KI-67 = 1%)

Cranio GTR

R Sylvian fissure

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 2%)

Surgical approach

2

23

Female

ACP (KI-67 = 8%)

1st cranio STR

2nd TSS

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 8%)

Surgical approach

4

32

Male

ACP (KI-67 = 2%)

Cranio GTR

R parietal lobe

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 5%)

CSF

10

Romani (2010) [24]

18

Female

ACP

Cranio GTR

Interhemisphere

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

4

Frangou (2009) [25]

10

Male

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio STR

3rd cranio STR + RT

R parietal lobe

Unclear

ACP

CSF

4

Elliott (2009) [26]

3

Female

ACP

Cranio GTR

Prepontine cistern

0.5

ACP

CSF

10

2

Male

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio GTR

3rd cranio GTR

L CPA

1.5

ACP

CSF

3.5

3

Female

ACP

Cranio GTR

R Sylvian fissure

2

ACP

Surgical approach

1.67

6

Male

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio GTR

L frontal lobe

1

ACP

CSF

7.08

Bikmaz (2009) [27]

37

Female

Unclear

Unclear

Prepontine

Unclear

ACP

CSF

15

32

Male

Unclear

GTR

R frontal lobe

Unclear

Non-ACP

Surgical approach

9

12

Male

Unclear

STR + RT

B CPA

Unclear

Unclear

CSF

12

Novák (2008) [28]

48

Male

Unclear

Unclear

Posterior fossa

Unclear

Unclear

CSF

19

Jeong (2006) [29]

8

Female

ACP (KI-67 = 3%)

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 3%)

Surgical approach

4

Yamada (2006) [31]

17

Female

ACP (KI-67 = 4.2%)

Cranio STR + RT

L frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP (KI-67 = 7.4%)

CSF

5

Bianco (2005) [31]

27

Female

ACP

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio GTR

L temporal lobe cortex

1

ACP

Surgical approach

10

Kawaguchi (2005) [32]

50

Female

Unclear

1st unclear

2nd cranio GTR

L frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

2

Ishiia (2004) [33]

2

Male

Unclear

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

0.17

Liu (2002) [34]

65

Female

Unclear

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

4.5 × 6.2 × 3

ACP

Surgical approach

3

Nomura (2002) [35]

17

Female

ACP (KI-67 = 3%)

1st cranio STR

2nd cranio STR + RT

R frontal and temporal lobe

Unclear

ACP

(F MIB = 6.2%, T MIB = 5.1%)

CSF

3.92

Fuentes (2002) [36]

32

Male

ACP

GTR

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

5

11

Male

ACP

GTR

Unclear

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

3

9

Male

ACP

GTR

R frontal lobe

R temporal lobe

Unclear

ACP

Surgical approach

10

Elmaci (2002) [37]

62

Female

PCP (KI-67 = 1%)

Cranio GTR

L temporal lobe

4 × 3 × 2.5

PCP (KI-67 = 3%)

CSF

2

Novegno (2002) [38]

6

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

1st L frontal lobe

2nd L pontine R cerebral basal

Unclear

Unclear

1st surgical approach

2nd CSF

1st 3

2nd 4

Lee (2001) [39]

26

Male

PCP

Cranio STR + GK

Lumber space

Unclear

PCP

CSF

1.58

Ito (2001) [40]

62

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

Unclear

ACP

CSF

3

Freitag (2001) [41]

61

Female

Unclear

Unclear

R frontal lobe

Unclear

Unclear

Surgical approach

5

Kim (2001) [42]

Child

Unclear

Unclear

Unclear

Internal auditory canal

Unclear

Unclear

CSF

Unclear

Gupta (1999) [43]

73

Male

ACP

Cranio GTR

L parietal lobe and L frontal lobe

2

ACP

CSF

7

Lee (1999) [44]

31

Male

Unclear

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

1

Unclear

Surgical approach

5

Israel (1995) [45]

12

Male

Unclear

Cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

4

Unclear

Surgical approach

2

Keohane (1994) [46]

7

Female

Unclear

Cranio STR + RT

L CPA

Unclear

ACP

CSF

26

Tomita (1993) [47]

Child

Unclear

Unclear

Unclear

R frontal lobe

Unclear

Unclear

Surgical approach

Unclear

Malik (1992) [48]

6

Male

ACP

1st cranio PR + RT

2nd cranio PR

3rd cranio GTR

R frontal lobe

3.5

ACP

Surgical approach

21

Tomita (1992) [49]

23

Female

Unclear

1st cranio PR

2nd RT

R CPA, interpeduncle, prepontine

Unclear

Unclear

CSF

25

Gökalp (1991) [50]

3

Male

Unclear

Cranio GTR

Fourth ventricle

3 × 3 × 3

Unclear

CSF

20

Ragoowansi (1991) [51]

47

Male

Unclear

1st stereotactic biopsy

2nd cranio GTR

R Sylvian fissure

2.5 × 1.5

Unclear

Surgical approach

1

Barloon (1988) [52]

5

Male

Unclear

1st cranio STR RT and cyst aspiration

R frontal lobe

Unclear

Unclear

Surgical approach

5

Baba (1978) [53]

7

Female

Unclear

Cranio STR

Prepontine C3

Unclear

Unclear

CSF

7