- Open Access
Intravascular embolization versus surgical resection for patients with scalp arteriovenous fistula
Chinese Neurosurgical Journal volume 5, Article number: 3 (2019)
Scalp arteriovenous fistula (sAVF) is a rare vascular disease; so far, the standard guidelines for the treatment of sAVF are still unclear. Since its complex vascular anatomical structure, surgical management of sAVF remains an enormous challenge.
Between March 2016 and October 2017, three patients with sAVF admitted to the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University were reviewed, and clinical characteristics, imaging features, and surgical outcomes were analyzed.
Three consecutive patients with sAVF were admitted to our hospital during the study period. Two patients received intravascular embolization and one patient received surgical resection. No procedure-related complications occurred after successfully treatment. During the long-term follow-up period, three patients recovered well and had no recurrence of lesion.
Either intravascular embolization or surgical resection is an effective therapy method for sAVF. Careful identification of angioarchitecture features contributes to successful treatment for the complex sAVF; therefore, it is recommended that neurosurgeons make the best treatment plan based on the location and number of the fistulas, feeding the artery, and draining the vein.
Scalp arteriovenous fistula (sAVF) is defined as an abnormal connection without a capillary vessel between the high-flow feeding artery and the low-flow draining veins of the scalp [1,2,3,4,5,6]. The etiology of sAVF may be congenitally caused or posteriori acquired and, in most patients, caused by a variety of head trauma which showed pulsatile scalp mass with vascular murmur [3, 4, 7,8,9,10]. Cerebral angiography is the diagnostic gold standard and can show location and number of the fistulas, expanded feeding arteries, as well as obviously tortuous draining vein. Operation is the main way of treatment for this rare vascular disease, including open surgical resection and intravascular embolization. In this paper, we describe three cases of sAVF who were successfully treated including two with intravascular embolization and one surgical resection. Furthermore, we reviewed the literature on sAVF and discussed the etiology, clinical features, and management strategies for this rare vascular disease.
The patient database at the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University was reviewed. The clinical characteristics, imaging features, and operative methods of all patients with sAVF were analyzed. The way of operation was decided by a cerebrovascular team which includes the experienced neurosurgeons and neurointerventional doctors, and the location and number of the fistulas, the feeding artery and draining vein, and the clinical condition and therapeutic preference of the patients were also to be considered. Simultaneously, the literature of sAVF in the past 15 years was summarized. The etiology, surgical methods, and outcome of the patients were investigated.
Between March 2016 and October 2017, three consecutive patients with sAVF were admitted to our hospital. A pulsating scalp mass accompanied by vascular murmur was observed in the three patients by physical examination. Cerebral angiography was performed before operation to identify feeding arteries and draining vein. One patient was treated using surgical resection, and two patients were treated by endovascular embolization. No procedure-related complications occurred after successful treatment. The three patients recovered well without any recurrence during clinical follow-up. In addition, the etiology, blood supply artery, drainage vein, and fistula of 27 cases of sAVF reported in the literature are shown in Table 1. Among them, interventional embolization was performed in 14 cases, surgical resection in 11 cases, and combination of 2 treatments in 2 cases (Table 2).
Case 1 report
One patient, a 38-year-old man, was admitted to our hospital on March 4, 2016. From 20 years ago, the patient found that a mass in the left frontotemporal part of the head gradually increased in size, which showed fluctuating feeling and blood flow sensation but no any pain or numbness. No other significant medical history but a history of brain trauma from a head gunshot wound 20 years ago. No abnormalities were available on neurologic examination except for blind eyes after head injury. Laboratory examinations, electrocardiogram, chest CT, and abdominal ultrasound also showed no obvious abnormalities. A CT angiography (CTA) was performed immediately after admission, showing abnormal blood vessels in the left frontotemporal scalp. Further digital subtraction angiography (DSA) demonstrated sAVF on this patient (Fig. 1). The patient was optimized and taken up for interventional embolization electively. Detailed informed consent was taken from the patient and his family members. The operation was performed under tracheal intubation and general anesthesia. After a 6F guiding catheter was placed into the left external carotid artery, the headway 17 microcatheter assisted by the synchro-10 microfilaments was used to select the left superficial temporal artery and other branches, and then Onyx-18 liquid agent was used to embolize lesions. Again, angiography showed no signs of AVF in the region of the left frontotemporal scalp and patency of blood flow in the left internal carotid artery. The amount of heparin used in the operation was 45 mg and intraoperative blood loss was less than 10 ml. After operation, all the problems were resolved and no operative complications occurred. The patient was followed-up clinically for nearly 2 years with normal symptoms and signs. Angiography examinations were normal without any recurrence.
Case 2 report
On July 29, 2016, a 43-year-old female patient was referred to our department due to a pulsating mass in the right top of the head. Twenty-three years ago, the patient found a soft mass with marked vascular fluctuations, but she did not go to the hospital for treatment. One year ago, the mass gradually increased to 4 × 6 cm without swelling, pain, numbness, or bleeding. The patient underwent head CTA, which showed that a serpiginous subcutaneous mass was in the region of the top head scalp. The patient received routine auxiliary examination after entering our department; all test results were within normal limits. Further DSA demonstrated a markedly tortuous and dilated bilateral occipital artery and superficial temporal artery branch feeding into a scalp vein, and blood flow within the lesion is extremely fast (Fig. 2). The patient signed the consent form for the surgery and selected interventional embolization. The operation was performed under tracheal intubation and general anesthesia. After the 6F guiding catheter was placed into the bilateral external carotid artery, several branches of bilateral occipital artery and superficial temporal artery were selected, and then Onyx-18 liquid agent was used to embolize lesions. Again, angiography showed that the blood circulation of the posterior circulation involved in the lesion basically disappeared. Intraoperative blood loss was 5 ml. No severe surgical complications appeared after operation, and the patient was discharged 5 days later. A long-term clinical follow-up demonstrated the complete disappearance of pulsating mass in the region of the right top scalp, and cerebral angiography at 18 months showed no evidence of recurrence.
Case 3 report
The other patient, a 26-year-old man, was admitted to our institution on October 14, 2017. The patient presented with pulsatile mass over the scalp without associated headache or dizziness. The patient had a history of brain trauma 8 years ago, and no family history of stroke or of other serious diseases. No history of surgery but a history of iohexol allergy. Physical examination indicated a 4 cm × 4 cm mass was located in the right occipital scalp and no other neurological positive signs. Post-admission CTA and further DSA confirmed the right occipital scalp arteriovenous fistula (right occipital artery supplied blood to the drainage of occipital scalp vein, Fig. 3), and the performance of cerebral angiography revealed no aneurysm or vessel abnormalities in other locations. After detailed information about the risk and the way of treatment, the patient chose surgical operation. The operation was performed under general anesthesia, and the patient takes the prone position. Scalp flap was devised depending on the scope of the lump and the cosmetic problem. Firstly, the right occipital artery was gently separated from the adjacent tissue, then it can be seen that the tension of the scalp mass decreased and the fluctuation disappeared after the blocking of the right occipital artery. Secondly, ablation electrode was used to coagulate the fistula, and finally, the diseased tissue was completely removed. Total excision of the scalp arteriovenous fistula was achieved, and intraoperative blood loss was less than 100 ml. Appropriate anti-inflammatory and analgesic treatment was given after operation. The patient recovered well, and no other complications developed. The pathologic examination strengthens the evidence of sAVF. The follow-up after 3 months and 6 months by physical and angiography examinations were normal without any signs of a fistula.
Scalp arteriovenous fistula (sAVF) is a rare vascular disease and previously named also as cirsoid aneurysms; therefore, only small case series have been reported by literature [1,2,3,4,5,6, 10]. It is widely believed that sAVF may be of either congenital or posteriori reason, and the latter one is the most common cause of lesion, which mainly results from head trauma or iatrogenic injury such as head surgery, hair transplantation, and scalp vein infusion [1,2,3,4, 7,8,9,10]. In most of the patients, superficial temporal artery (STA) was involved. After injury of the STA, hemodynamic begins to change and is characterized by high flow from the abundant feeding artery leading to a progressive venous dilation in the scalp [2, 3, 5, 8, 9]. The sAVF generally present with small subcutaneous swelling in the beginning, which can enlarge to become a pulsatile scalp mass over time and cause severe cosmetic deformity [2, 8, 9]. These lesions can also bring about various clinical signs and symptoms such as tinnitus, headache, hemorrhage, epilepsy, local allodynia, bruits, and scalp necrosis [3,4,5, 8, 9, 11,12,13,14,15]. The three patients we presented showed a pulsatile mass on the scalp without other severe symptoms. When the main feeding arteries are depressed, pulsatile sounds on auscultation will decrease and eventually disappear [8, 16]. Although physical examination is generally sufficient for diagnosis of sAVF, cerebral angiography is the gold standard diagnostic tool and can clearly show the fistulas, supplying artery and drainage vein [8, 11, 14, 16, 17].
In recent reports, therapeutic regimen varied depending on the type and location of the disease; however, it is also opted by physician preference. Two treatment options are currently available for scalp AVF: surgical excision and intravascular embolization. In the 27 cases recently reported, 11 were by surgical resection, 14 by intravascular embolization, and 2 by a combined treatment. The indication of the operation includes prevention of bleeding and relief of the cosmetic problem of the pulsatile mass and other symptoms such as local allodynia and tinnitus [18, 19]. The cases of intravascular embolization increased compared before as a result of the improvement of interventional technique, but radical surgical excision is still a necessary therapeutic method [2, 14, 18]. The advantages of surgical resection are lower costs, low incidence of complications, and lower recurrence rates, as well as it does not bear the risk of cosmetic deformity [4, 11, 18, 20]. Due to a high risk of recurrence in the arteriovenous fistulas, curative resection of these lesions after ligation of blood supply arteries is essential . Scalp bleeding often occurred in those patients with incomplete excision of the fistula [14, 18]. Besides, primary closure of the scalp may not be easy after total excision of complex sAVFs, which is also prone to scalp necrosis. To avoid massive bleeding, detailed dissection of the abnormal vessels and careful removal of the lesion are recommended . In order to achieve a completely cured surgical outcome, it is necessary to ligate the proximal feeder and remove the draining veins [4, 11]. Postoperative vasospasm is also a possible reason that may lead to a wrong thought of complete excision of sAVF . The long-term follow-up of our patients showed no problems or recurrence. Therefore, cerebral angiography should be performed several months after operation to ensure the complete excision of lesion as well as no any recurrence.
Although total resection of the vascular malformation can achieve a perfect cure, ligation of proximal feeders may lead to distal tissue ischemia or insufficiency of the resection may bring about patency of the fistula due to collateral feeding artery . In addition, complete resection may often lead to massive hemorrhage if the fistula is inadvertently punctured . With the advances in interventional techniques and embolization materials, intravascular treatment is becoming more accepted as an efficient alternative to open surgery. The major point of endovascular therapy is to obstruct the abnormal arteriovenous shunt. Various intravascular approaches including transarterial, transvenous, and direct puncture for the remedy of sAVF have been reported in the recent literature [1, 5, 13, 16, 17]. The advantages of endovascular embolization are small trauma and quick recovery, but for many large supply arteries and draining veins, it is easy to recur after embolization, and the operation cost is high. At the junction of the feeding artery and the draining vein, the flow-guided microcatheter can be used to reach into the fistula. This is the main fistula location that must be successfully embolized to ensure full closure and also will not lead to ischemia in distal tissue due to interruption of arterial blood flow. Because of relative simplicity and safety, it is currently considered that the first choice of treatment is occlusion of fistula through Onyx liquid embolic material [3, 16, 17]. However, due to the extreme bending of the external carotid artery branches, transarterial access can sometimes be difficult to reach fistula. Especially in patients with complex multiple fistulas, it is difficult to fully obstruct all blood supply arteries by the transarterial approach . So, interventional embolization for each blood supply artery may be inadequate or infeasible unless reaching into the venous side of fistula [1, 3, 5]. We reviewed the literature and found that two cases of recurrence were complex sAVF with multiple fistulas, in which surgical resection is also usually required and is facilitated by subtotal occlusion of this complex sAVF by embolization . Besides, Cil B et al. reported successful treatment of sAVF by direct puncture . In the this technique, usually under temporary compression of venous drainage, the sclerosing agent or embolic agent is retrogradely penetrated into the feeding arteries of the fistula and into the draining veins in the vicinity of the arteriovenous connection. The advantages of direct puncture are no use of microcatheters, less X-ray exposure, and short operation time.
Either intravascular embolization or surgical resection is an effective therapy method for sAVF. Careful identification of angioarchitecture features contributes to successful treatment for the complex sAVF; therefore, it is recommended that neurosurgeons make the best treatment plan based on the location and number of the fistulas, feeding artery, and draining vein.
Computed tomography angiography
Digital subtraction angiography
External carotid artery
External jugular veins
Middle meningeal artery
Posterior auricular artery
Scalp arteriovenous fistula
Superficial frontotemporal vein
Superior ophthalmic veins
Superficial temporal artery
Ni W, Tian Y, Gu Y, Mao Y. Transvenous endovascular treatment for scalp arteriovenous fistulas: results with combined use of Onyx and coils. World Neurosurg. 2017;107:692–7.
Xue B, Yi L, Chao Y. Surgical resection of a complex multiple scalp Avf without preoperative embolization: a case report. Turk Neurosurg. 2015;25:638–42.
Dalyai RT, Schirmer CM, Malek AM. Transvenous balloon-protected embolization of a scalp arteriovenous fistula using Onyx liquid embolic. Acta Neurochir. 2011;153:1285–90.
Dabus G, Pizzolato R, Lin E, Kreusch A, Linfante I. Endovascular treatment for traumatic scalp arteriovenous fistulas: results with Onyx embolization. J Neurointerv Surg. 2014;6:405–8.
Cil B, Topcuoglu OM, Peynircioglu B, Arat A, Vargel I. Percutaneous treatment of scalp arteriovenous fistulas by direct puncture and polydocanol sclerotherapy: report of 2 cases with long-term follow-up. Clin Neuroradiol. 2018;28:609–12.
Asai K, Tani S, Imai Y, Mineharu Y, Sakai N. Traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery. J Surg Case Rep. 2015. https://doi.org/10.1093/jscr/rjv156.
Kim DM, Benndorf G, Von Moers A, Campi A, Lehmann TN. Spontaneous scalp arteriovenous fistula in a child with Hartnup disease. J Endovasc Ther. 2004;11:348–50.
El Shazly AA, Saoud KM. Results of surgical excision of cirsoid aneurysm of the scalp without preoperative interventions. Asian J Neurosurg. 2012;7:191–6.
Gurkanlar D, Gonul M, Solmaz I, Gonul E. Cirsoid aneurysms of the scalp. Neurosurg Rev. 2006;29:208–12.
Ki HJ, Lee HK, Hur JW, Lee JW. Post-traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the scalp. J Korean Neurosurg Soc. 2015;58:298–300.
Li F, Zhu S, Liu Y, Chen Y, Chi L, Chen G, et al. Traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery. J Clin Neurosci. 2007;14:595–600.
Amlashi SF, Riffaud L, Morandi X. Arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery: an exceptional complication of the pterional approach. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 2004;75:1077–8.
Youn SW, Lee NJ, Suh SI, Kang SH. Direct-puncture embolization of scalp arteriovenous fistulae. Neurol Med Chir (Tokyo). 2012;52:525–8.
Dogan S, Cinar C, Demirpolat G, Memis A. Endovascular treatment of AVF after hair transplantation. Cardiovasc Intervent Radiol. 2008;31(Suppl 2):S128–30.
Tauro LF, Suhith G, Shetty P, Rao D. Cirsoid aneurysm of scalp. J Neurosci Rural Pract. 2012;3:95–6.
Yang M, Pan L, Cai MJ, Ma LT, Xu GZ, Li J, et al. Spontaneous arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery: diagnosis and treatment. Clin Neurol Neurosurg. 2014;123:18–24.
Hage ZA, Few JW, Surdell DL, Adel JG, Batjer HH, Bendok BR. Modern endovascular and aesthetic surgery techniques to treat arteriovenous malformations of the scalp: case illustration. Surg Neurol. 2008;70:198–203.
Senoglu M, Yasim A, Gokce M, Senoglu N. Nontraumatic scalp arteriovenous fistula in an adult: technical report on an illustrative case. Surg Neurol. 2008;70:194–7.
Whiteside OJ, Monksfield P, Steventon NB, Byrne J, Burton MJ. Endovascular embolization of a traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery. J Laryngol Otol. 2005;119:322–4.
Zheng F, Augustus Pitts H, Goldbrunner R, Krischek B. Traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the scalp in the left temporoparietal region with intra- and extracranial blood supply. Case Rep Vasc Med. 2016. https://doi.org/10.1155/2016/8671472.
Corr PD. Cirsoid aneurysm of the scalp. Singap Med J. 2007;48:268–9.
Champeaux C, Jecko V, Penchet G, Chibbaro S. Scalp arteriovenous fistula following hair transplantation. Clin Neuroradiol. 2014;24:285–8.
Moran AM, Aleman TS, Gausas RE, Fogt F. Traumatic arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery: a histopathologic report. Ophthalmic Plast Reconstr Surg. 2013;29:e126–8.
Miekisiak G, Mis M, Sandler A, Druszcz A. Iatrogenic arteriovenous fistula of the superficial temporal artery. Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2008;12:219-21.
The authors thank the following funding agencies for their support: National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81671160), National Natural Science Foundation of China (No. 81571159), and 13th Five-Year National Key Research Project of China (2016YFC1300800; 2016YFC1300804; 2016YFC1300805).
Availability of data and materials
Please contact author for data requests.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study was approved by the ethics committee of the First Affiliated Hospital of Chongqing Medical University.
Consent for publication
All presentations of case reports have consent to publish.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.